About this calculator
A higher deductible lowers your premium, but you pay more when you make a claim. Whether it is worth it depends on how much you save each year and how often you expect to claim.
This calculator shows the break-even point, how often you could claim before the higher deductible stops paying off, and the expected yearly cost of each choice. It works for car, home and renters insurance.
How to use it
- Enter the premium and deductible for the low option.
- Enter the premium and deductible for the high option.
- Choose how often you expect to claim, then compare.
What the inputs mean
- How often you expect a claim
- Many drivers and homeowners claim far less than once every five years. Use your own history as a guide.
Worked example
A $500 deductible costs $1,600 a year and a $1,000 deductible $1,400. You save $200 a year but pay $500 more per claim, so the break-even is one claim every 2.5 years. If you claim once every 5 years, the high deductible saves about $100 a year on average.
The formula
Break-even years = (high − low deductible) ÷ yearly premium saving
Good to know
- Only choose a deductible you could pay tomorrow from savings without borrowing.
- Put the premium you save into an emergency fund to cover the higher deductible if you need it.
Questions people ask
Does the deductible apply to every claim?
For car, home and renters insurance it usually applies to each claim. Health insurance deductibles work once per year instead.
Will a claim raise my premium?
It can, which is another reason many people avoid small claims and choose a higher deductible.
Is a higher deductible always cheaper?
Only if you claim less often than the break-even. If you claim often, the low deductible costs less.
Last reviewed November 4, 2026. Results are estimates based on the values you enter and the formula shown. They are not financial, tax, legal or medical advice. Report a problem with this calculator
