Percentage Change Traps: Why −50% and +50% Don’t Cancel Out

Percentage changes are everywhere: prices, salaries, investment returns, survey results. They are also easy to misread, because every percentage change is measured against a starting value, and that base keeps moving.

The formula

change = (new − old) ÷ old × 100

From 80 to 100 is (100 − 80) ÷ 80 = +25%. From 100 back to 80 is (80 − 100) ÷ 100 = −20%. Same gap, different percentages, because the base changed.

Trap 1: a fall and an equal rise don’t cancel

Example

An investment worth $100 falls 50% to $50. It then rises 50%, to $75. It needed a 100% gain to get back to $100.

The deeper the fall, the larger the recovery needed: a 20% drop needs a 25% gain; a one-third drop needs a 50% gain.

Trap 2: averaging percentage returns

A year of +50% followed by a year of −50% averages to 0%, but you have lost 25% of your money. When returns compound, the fair summary is the compound annual growth rate, not the simple average.

Trap 3: percentage points vs percent

If a rate moves from 4% to 5%, it has risen by 1 percentage point and by 25 percent. Both are true; they answer different questions. Headlines sometimes pick whichever sounds more dramatic. When the values are already percentages, “points” is the clearer word for the plain difference.

Trap 4: small bases

Going from 2 complaints to 4 is a 100% increase. Going from 2,000 to 2,400 is a 20% increase but 200 times as many extra complaints. Always look at the absolute numbers next to the percentage.

Bonus: repeated changes compound

Three years of 10% growth is not 30%; it is 1.1 × 1.1 × 1.1 = 1.331, a 33.1% rise. The same applies to price rises and salary increases.

A quick checklist

  • What was the starting value?
  • Is this a change in percent or in percentage points?
  • How big are the underlying numbers?
  • Is it one change, or several stacked together?
Percentage Change CalculatorThe percent increase or decrease between two numbers.Open calculator

Frequently asked questions

How do I undo a percentage change?

Divide by the multiplier. After a 25% rise, divide by 1.25. The reverse percentage calculator does it for you.

Can a decrease be more than 100%?

Only if the value goes negative, such as profit turning into a loss.

plw95

Writes and checks the guides and calculators on FinQal. Every worked example in this article was checked against the matching calculator.

Keep reading