Stacked Discounts and Other Sale Math That Fools Shoppers

Sales are designed to feel generous. A little arithmetic shows how generous they really are, and which of two offers is better.

Stacked discounts multiply, they don’t add

“40% off, plus an extra 20% at checkout” sounds like 60% off. The second discount applies to the already reduced price.

Example

A $150 jacket:

  • 40% off: $150 × 0.60 = $90
  • Extra 20% off: $90 × 0.80 = $72

You save $78, which is 52%, not 60%. A true 60% discount would make it $60.

effective discount = 1 − (1 − d₁) × (1 − d₂)

The order doesn’t matter: 20% then 40% gives the same $72.

Buy one, get one half price

Two $40 items with the second at 50% off cost $60 instead of $80. That is 25% off the pair, and only a deal if you wanted two.

Money off vs percent off

Which is better on a $100 order: $20 off or 15% off? $20 off is 20%, so it wins. On a $200 order, 15% off saves $30 and wins instead. The crossover is where the fixed amount equals the percentage: here, $133.33.

The “was” price

A discount is only as good as the price it starts from. If an item usually sells for $90 and is listed as “was $150, now $90”, the discount is 0% in practice. Price history tools and a quick search help here.

Tax comes last

Sales tax is normally charged on the discounted price, so a discount also saves the tax on the amount taken off.

Quick mental method

Multiply by what you keep. 40% off means you pay 0.6; another 20% off means 0.8 of that. 0.6 × 0.8 = 0.48, so you pay 48% and save 52%.

Discount CalculatorSale price and savings, including a second discount stacked on top.Open calculator

Frequently asked questions

Is 30% off then 30% off the same as 60% off?

No. It is 1 − 0.7 × 0.7 = 51% off.

How do I find the original price from a sale price?

Divide by what you kept. A $60 price after 25% off was $60 ÷ 0.75 = $80.

plw95

Writes and checks the guides and calculators on FinQal. Every worked example in this article was checked against the matching calculator.

Keep reading